Disclosure - We are not paid for any of our product reviews. Our analysis and ranking are unbiased. We may receive compensation if a purchase is made, which enables us to provide this free service. Details.

3 BEST IDENTITY THEFT PROTECTION PROVIDERS OF 2017

#1 Identity Guard

9.4/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

9

Price & Value

10

Customer Service

9.5

Miscellaneous

9

Overall

9.4

Pros

  • Identity Guard Cost: Low-price leader starting at $8.99

  • $1 million in identity theft insurance. Details in Full Review

  • Monitors all three credit bureaus

  • Access to credit scores, alerts, and more with mobile app

  • Three clear and competitively priced plans to choose from

Cons

  • Offers great customer service, but only available Mon - Sat

IdentityForce

9.3/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

9

Price & Value

9

Customer Service

9.5

Miscellaneous

9.5

Overall

9.3

Pros

  • IdentityForce offers a personalized identity health score

  • Keeps track of credit score with all three credit bureaus

  • Provides credit reports for everyone listed on your plan

  • Anti-keylogging and anti-phishing software

Cons

  • Offers only two plans, so potential limited flexibility

LifeLock

9.2/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

9.5

Price & Value

9

Customer Service

9.5

Miscellaneous

9

Overall

9.2

Pros

  • LifeLock® Cost: Low-price with plans starting at $9.99

  • Provides alerts on changes to bank accounts

  • $1 million guarantee for id recovery; see disclaimer ‡

  • Over 10,000 black market internet sites are monitored

Cons

  • While an industry leader, had two legal issues with the FTC

Providers Worth Considering

Although the companies below didn't quite make our 2017 certification list, they're still worth considering.

#4 TrustedID

8.7/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

9

Price & Value

9

Customer Service

9

Miscellaneous

8

Overall

8.5

Read Full Review

Pros

  • Keep track of and request your medical statements

  • Trusted ID has option to include live-in family members

  • Personalized identity theft risk score

  • Lost wallet protection

Cons

  • Limited service offering; no financial account monitoring

#5 Experian’s ProtectMyID

8.5/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

9

Price & Value

8

Customer Service

9

Miscellaneous

8

Overall

8.5

READ FULL REVIEW

Pros

  • Experian’s ProtectMyID offers all-clear alerts

  • Experian credit report checked every day

  • National and credit report change of address monitoring

  • Lost wallet protection

Cons

  • Does not offer credit reports from other two credit bureaus

#6 MetLife Defender

8.4/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

8.5

Price & Value

8

Customer Service

8.5

Miscellaneous

8.5

Overall

8.4

READ FULL REVIEW

Pros

  • Lost wallet protection

  • Cyber bullying protection available for children

  • MetLife Defender has a $5 million service guarantee

  • Child under the age of 26 can be included on your plan

Cons

  • Does not offer credit score monitoring

#7 ID Watchdog

8.5/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

8.5

Price & Value

9

Customer Service

8.5

Miscellaneous

8

Overall

8.4

READ FULL REVIEW

Pros

  • ID Watchdog has advanced identity monitoring

  • NPI monitoring available for healthcare professionals

  • Monitors public records for use of Social Security number

  • Customers with pre-existing conditions can enroll

Cons

  • Does not offer computer protective software

#8 Equifax ID Patrol

8.5/10

Identity Protection & Recovery

8.5

Price & Value

8

Customer Service

9

Miscellaneous

8.5

Overall

8.3

READ FULL REVIEW

Pros

  • Unlimited access to Equifax report with option to lock it

  • Other credit bureaus can be alerted to potential fraud

  • Monitor up to two adults and four children

  • 24/7 service

Cons

  • Does not offer computer protective software

DEALS & PROMOS

Exclusive Deals Negotiated by InHomeSafetyGuide.org

Being the most trusted online resource for identity theft protection reviews allows us to negotiate exclusive deals and promotions from our top-rated merchants.  Our Deals area is reserved for InHomeSafetyGuide.org Certified Partners and exclusive for our site visitors.  Please note all promotions and deals are subject to change at any time.

 

See all deals

HOW WE RANK

Unbiased, comprehensive and trusted

Created by a group of technology, security, safety and testing experts, the InHomeSafetyGuide.org Review Team is dedicated to providing consumers with the most unbiased, comprehensive and trusted reviews anywhere.  Check out InHomeSafetyGuide.org’s testing lab’s methodologies and rating criteria.

 

How We Rank

BUYER'S GUIDE

Learn the in's and out's before you purchase

With so many identity theft protection products on the market today, and so many factors to consider, finding the identity theft protection solution that’s right for you can be daunting. To help you narrow down your choices, we’ve created a checklist on what to look for when purchasing an identity theft protection product.

 

See The Buyers Guide

OUR VISITORS LOVE US

Providing buying advice on products and services designed to save lives is serious business. At InHomeSafetyGuide.org, we take this responsibility seriously. It's one of the reasons we value reviews of our service left on TRUSTPILOT.com – the most trusted review platform in the world with over 26 million unfiltered reviews of 152,000+ businesses. Over 150 customers have reviewed our service, awarding us an average score of 8.5+ out of 10, a rating of "GREAT." But don’t take our word for it. Read our reviews.

I never thought a lot about identity theft, until someone close to me experienced it. It took her over a year of dealing with the mess before the whole thing was resolved because she was dealing with the problem on her own.I knew I needed to invest in an identity theft protection plan, but I had no idea just how many there are!

Fortunately, I stumbled across inhomesafetyguide.org. With the clear reviews on the website, I was able to make a confident, informed choice.

I’m so glad John and the rest of the team are willing to take the time to provide unbiased reviews that make the shopping experience much simpler. Thanks guys!

Rating: ★★★★★ 

Jill R.

Omaha, NE