View Best Identity Theft Protection for 2024

Identity Theft Protection | Buyers Guide For 2024

There is nothing more important than protecting your identity. With the rise of identity theft crimes in the United States, it’s becoming difficult to track all of your personal information on your own. That’s why so many people have turned to an identity theft protection company. Many of the best identity theft protection plans are extremely affordable. Companies offer a wide variety of services that we review in detail so you can find a plan that’s right for you and your family.

All of the items listed below are services that we take into account when conducting our identity theft protection reviews and lifelock reviews. These are services that you should look for before you sign up for the best identity theft protection plan to fit your needs.

1. Identity Protection
Early detection is extremely important when it comes to keeping your identity safe. The best identity theft protection companies:

  • Monitor the internet for your information
  • Monitor public and court records
  • Monitor medical and insurance records
  • Monitor your credit accounts
  • Keep tabs on black market sites
  • Offer timely fraud alerts
  • Offer junk mail opt-out services

2. Identity Recovery
It is important to understand that even the best identity theft protection companies can’t keep your information from getting stolen. Instead, they monitor your information and offer identity recovery services that include:

  • Identity recovery specialists who are available to assist you
  • Assistance for a variety of fraud situations including medical, criminal, and tax fraud
  • Lost wallet protection services
  • Customer service reps that offer assistance and support, in addition to speaking directly with the three major credit bureaus
  • Identity recovery resources on their website
  • A quality guarantee or insurance policy that is included with your plan

3. Price and Value

The services that identity theft protection agencies offer are extremely important, but all of those services aren’t very helpful if they’re out of your price range. However, an inexpensive plan may not be the right choice either. The cheapest identity theft protection plans aren’t likely to offer comprehensive services. When reviewing identity theft protection agencies, we weigh cost against value so you can get a balanced plan that doesn’t break the bank.

4. Credit Monitoring

Keeping a close eye on your credit reports is one of the best ways to prevent credit card fraud and identity theft. Although you can monitor this information on your own, identity theft protection agencies can make it much easier for you to keep track of your credit scores. The very best identity theft protection agencies:

  • Monitor all three credit bureaus, including Experian, Equifax, and Transunion
  • Provide you with your credit scores, free of charge, multiple times a year
  • Offer timely credit card fraud and identity theft alerts
  • Communicate directly with credit bureaus when identity theft is suspected

5. Customer Service
Even the most comprehensive identity theft protection services are useless if you can’t get the assistance you need from their customer service department. Details you’ll want to look at before settling on an identity theft plan include:

  • Flexible customer service hours, up to 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
  • The ability to work with a single identity theft recovery specialist throughout the process
  • Free trial periods of up to 30 days
  • Web security and encryption on their website that keeps your personal information safe

6. Insurance Quality and Guarantees
Every identity theft protection company offers an insurance policy or guarantee with their services, but these policies and guarantees vary widely depending on the company. Details you might want to look for in an insurance policy or guarantee include:
  • Assistance paying for attorneys
  • Travel expense reimbursement
  • Paying for lost wages
  • Spending up to a certain amount to restore your identity to pre-theft levels

7. Plan Options
Having choices is important, especially if you’re on a budget. When searching for an identity theft protection plan, you may want to look for a company that offers multiple choices that may include:
  • Options to include other adults in your plan
  • Options to include children in your plan
  • Different tiers of service with different prices

8. Extras
Every good identity theft protection agency should do something special that makes them different from the others. Some of the extras offered by some companies include:

  • Computer software that includes antivirus, anti-keylogging, and anti-phishing programs
  • Additional monitoring services for other family members at no extra cost
  • Recovery services are offered, even if you weren’t a customer when your identity was stolen
  • Online resources, tips, and FAQ pages to help you keep your identity secure
  • Junk mail opt-out services
  • Free trial periods

Frequently Asked ID Theft Protection Questions

Q. What is identity theft?

Show Answer

A. Identity theft is a broad concept that encompasses a wide variety of situations. However, every instance of identity theft involves a thief using your personal information in order to steal your money, open new accounts in your name, or obtain services. Ways they can use your personal information include:

  • Opening new credit card accounts
  • Using funds in your bank account
  • Taking out loans for new cars and new homes
  • Renting homes, property, vehicles, and more
  • Obtaining medical treatment and charging it to your insurance
  • Using your information when committing a crime

Q. Is credit card fraud and identity theft the same thing?

Show Answer

A. Although credit card fraud and identity theft seem similar, they are actually quite different.

Credit card fraud occurs when a thief obtains your account information and uses the funds to make purchases. If you report fraud on your credit card quickly, you can usually recoup the lost funds with little to no effect to your credit account or credit score. Most credit card companies and banks have policies and plans in place for limiting a card holder’s responsibility when it comes to paying for fraudulent charges.

Identity theft, on the other hand, means that the thief has obtained your personal information. By using this information, an identity thief can do much more than charge purchases to your accounts. Identity thieves can use your name, address, social security number, and medical information to open new accounts, take out loans, obtain medical treatments, and more.

Q. How do identity theft protection agencies protect my information?

Show Answer

A. In an attempt to keep important information protected, many people turn to an identity theft protection agency. They offer a variety of services that are geared toward protecting your information that include:

  • Monitoring the internet for use of your personal information
  • Keeping tabs on black market sites to ensure your information isn’t being bought and sold
  • Monitoring your credit accounts for fraudulent activity
  • Offering junk mail opt-out services to keep your personal information out of the garbage
  • Offering timely fraud alerts
  • Some identity theft protection companies offer software with their plans

No identity theft protection agency can guarantee that your identity won’t be stolen, but they can keep a close eye on your accounts so identity theft can be dealt with quickly.

Q. How do I know if I’m at risk of having my identity stolen?

Show Answer

A. Identity theft is on the rise, which means more people are at risk of having their identities stolen than ever before. However, your habits can greatly impact the likelihood of whether or not your identity will be stolen. Some identity theft protection companies offer a personalized identity health score, but you can also take the Identity Theft Risk Assessment Quiz from Rutgers to see just how at risk you are.

Don’t forget about the other members of your family! Believe it or not, but children are at a greater risk of identity theft than adults, so you may want to consider a plan that monitors your children’s information as well.

Q. How can you tell if your identity has been stolen?

Show Answer

A. Keeping your identity protected means knowing the signs that it has been compromised:

  • Your credit cards get declined unexpectedly
  • Strange charges begin appearing on your credit card statements
  • Money goes missing from your bank account
  • Your credit score takes an unexpected dive
  • Personal information on your credit reports is inaccurate

The earlier you identify identity theft, the easier it is to fix, which is why so many people turn to an identity theft protection company.

Q. What is the difference between a $1 million guarantee and a $1 million insurance policy?

Show Answer

A. The services provided by identity theft protection agencies can vary widely, but every company has a guarantee or insurance policy. However, there are a few key differences between the two.

In general, a $1 million guarantee means that the company will spend up to $1 million dollars to reestablish your identity to pre-theft levels. That may mean that they are willing to pay attorneys and fees, but they may not be willing to provide you with cash.

A $1 million insurance policy means that the company will spend up to $1 million to reestablish your identity, but they are also likely to provide you with emergency funds and lost wages.

Although these are general guidelines, the details of each policy differ greatly depending on the company. Some companies with guarantees may be willing to cover lost wages, while some companies with insurance policies may not be able to provide you with emergency cash. It’s important to understand the guarantees and policies of the companies you are considering before choosing a plan.

Q. What do identity thieves do with my information?

Show Answer

A. Identity thieves can get pretty creative when it comes to using your information. In addition to well-known issues, like draining your bank account and opening new accounts, there are many other ways an identity thief can ruin your good name. They can:

  • Sell your information on the black market
  • Charge their utilities in your name
  • Obtain a cell phone
  • Apply for a job
  • Obtain student financial aid
  • File fraudulent tax returns
  • Obtain medical care
  • Commit a crime

The possibilities really are endless, which is why it is so important to keep an eye on your personal information and credit accounts.

Q. Who is at risk of having their identity stolen?

Show Answer

A. Although anyone can have their identity stolen, there are a few groups of people that are more at risk:

  • Social media users – Unfortunately, sharing all that personal information about you and your family on social media can make you an easy target for identity thieves.
  • Using credit cards – Every time you use a plastic card, you are putting your information at risk. If the businesses you frequent experience a data breach, your personal information could be in jeopardy.
  • Children – Youngsters receive a social security number at birth, but this number isn’t likely to be monitored until much later in life, giving an identity thief plenty of time to ruin your child’s identity and credit.
  • Wealthy people – Not only do wealthy people have more money to steal, they also tend to have multiple accounts, making it more difficult for them to monitor their personal information.

Even accessing personal accounts on your cell phone can put you at risk of having your identity stolen! The bottom line is that no one is immune from identity theft.

Q. Who is the typical identity thief?

Show Answer

A. When you think of the typical identity thief, you’re probably thinking about someone living across the country or halfway around the world. Although thieves can be complete strangers, they are actually more likely to be someone you know.

Many identity thieves turn out to be neighbors, friends, colleagues, household employees, and even brothers, sisters, cousins, and children. Passing acquaintances, like school employees, credit card companies, restaurant employees, and retail stores can steal your information. Anyone who has access to your personal information can become a potential identity thief.

Q. How do I monitor my credit accounts?

Show Answer

A. One of the best ways to monitor your personal information is to keep tabs on your credit accounts. However, there are three separate credit bureaus that you need to monitor regularly. Many of the best identity theft protection companies do this for you, but you can also check your credit reports on your own:

Everyone is entitled to a free credit report from each bureau once a year. To obtain your annual credit reports for free, visit

Q. Can I recover money that was stolen from my accounts?

Show Answer

A. You can recover money that was stolen from your accounts. However, most identity theft protection agencies will not replace the stolen funds in your account. That’s because you are not legally responsible for paying fraudulent debts as a result of identity theft.

Most credit card companies and banks have policies in place to restore funds to your account. The quicker you can identify fraud, the more likely you will be to recover those funds. An identity theft protection company can help you talk to creditors to ensure that those funds get returned to your account.

Q. Is it a good idea to get a new social security number if my identity was stolen?

Show Answer

A. Replacing your social security number may seem like the easiest route to regaining your identity, but it’s not usually the best option.

You’ll have to keep track of two sets of personal information that are associated with each number. In addition, changing your social security number can set off some red flags. Changing social security numbers is associated with imposters, not victims, so a future employer or creditor may be hesitant to work with you.



We review the best and worst companies. 100% free report!

Our picks for the best identity theft protection for 2018.  Independent and unbiased – our team of security experts conduct methodical and detailed tests on today’s most popular identity theft protection. The result is evidence-backed reviews and ratings you can trust to make smarter, more informed choices in helping to keep you and your loved ones secure.


See 2024’s Best Identity Theft Protection


Exclusive Deals Negotiated by

Being the most trusted online resource for identity theft protection reviews allows us to negotiate exclusive deals and promotions from our top-rated id theft protection providers.  Our Deals area is reserved for Certified Partners and exclusive for our site visitors.  Please note all promotions and deals are subject to change at any time.


See all deals


Understand our passion and how it all started

Learn how an evening of online research for a family member in need of a home safety device ignited relenting movement to build, nurture and protect the most trusted online resource for providing unbiased, comprehensive, and needed reviews for products and services to ensure you and your loved ones stay safe at home.


Meet our Founders

Created by a group of technology, security, and testing experts, has been providing in-depth and unbiased reviews since 2015. We are located in San Francisco with our Testing Labs stationed just out side Sacramento, CA.